A2 Refereed review article in a scientific journal
Value-aware nutrition science: building credibility through reflexivity
Authors: Penders Bart; Bordoni Alessandra; Daniel Hannelore; Larqué-Daza Elvira; Laitinen Kirsi; Perez-Cueto Federico J. A.; on behalf of FENS WG2
Publisher: Springer Science and Business Media LLC
Publication year: 2025
Journal: European Journal of Nutrition
Journal name in source: European journal of nutrition
Journal acronym: Eur J Nutr
Article number: 229
Volume: 64
Issue: 5
ISSN: 1436-6207
eISSN: 1436-6215
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00394-025-03699-6
Web address : https://doi.org/10.1007/s00394-025-03699-6
Purpose: Values can influence various aspects of scientific research, including research questions, methodologies, interpretations, and applications of scientific knowledge. Instead of pursuing value-free science, the scientific community recognizes the importance of value-aware science, which acknowledges the role of values in scientific inquiry but emphasizes transparency and accountability. Conflicts of interest statements often focus only on financial ties.
Methods: We argue for the inclusion of positionality statements in nutrition science, similar to practices in the social sciences and humanities. Positionality statements highlight the influence of the researcher's position, background, and values on scientific inquiry, promoting transparency, reflexivity, and dialogue within the scientific community. We advocate for a shift towards a perspectival epistemology that recognizes the value of diverse perspectives and contributes to a more robust and reliable scientific knowledge.
Results: We include case studies demonstrating different styles of positionality statements and addresses potential critiques of positionality, including concerns about subjectivity and equating individuals with their social identities.
Conclusion: Overall, we conclude that embracing value-awareness and positionality can lead to a more credible and socially engaged nutrition science.
Funding information in the publication:
For an extensive overview of our interests and our positions, see the case studies in this text. This work was supported by the Federation of European Nutrition Societies.