B1 Other refereed article (e.g., editorial, letter, comment) in a scientific journal
The ethics of narrative : a readers’ dialogue
Authors: Domańska, Ewa; Doran, Robert; Muchowski, Jakub; Paul, Herman; Pihlainen, Kalle; Valderrama, Miguel
Publisher: Routledge
Publication year: 2024
Journal: Rethinking History
Journal name in source: Rethinking History
Volume: 28
Issue: 3
First page : 422
Last page: 456
ISSN: 1364-2529
eISSN: 1470-1154
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13642529.2024.2357967
Web address : https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/13642529.2024.2357967
This article is a collaborative commentary on the first volume of a two-part anthology of works by Hayden White, The Ethics of Narrative, edited by Robert Doran. Informed by the collection and inspired by the co-authors, in this paper we discuss White’s writing. Herman Paul compares White’s constructivism with that of Berger and Luckmann, and discusses the extent to which the tools of historical narrative criticism developed by White are expeditious in analyzing stories about the climate crisis. Kalle Pihlainen captures White’s writing in a three-stage process of emancipatory politics of history, to further reconfigure it using the concept of fidelity. Jakub Muchowski writes about the relationship between the titular ethics and politics, asking to what extent White regarded them as separate spheres of practice, and whether in choosing the former White was apolitical. Ewa Domańska considers how White’s critical approach to history might help to explore possibilities of bridging Indigenous and Western approaches to the past as well as reflects on White’s attitude toward metaphysics. Finally, Miguel Valderrama considers the ways in which White uses the concept of event. The exchange closes with Robert Doran’s response to all the commentaries.
Funding information in the publication:
Ewa Domańska’s contribution was inspired by her cooperation with the TEAM project ‘Core concepts of Historical Thinking’ of the Foundation for Polish Science (Agreement No. POIR.04.04.00-00-5C1E/17-00). Jakub Muchowski contribution to this paper was possible thanks to the support of by National Science Centre, Poland (Grant Number 2020/39/D/HS3/01262). Kalle Pihlainen’s contribution was made possible by his participation in the ‘Temporality in Predictive Processing’ project (Research Council of Finland; Grant Number: 342166), led by Valtteri Arstila.
