A1 Refereed original research article in a scientific journal
"The whole is greater than the sum of its parts" – True, false or meaningless?
Authors: Itkonen Esa
Publication year: 2016
Journal: The public journal of semiotics
Volume: 7
Issue: 2
First page : 21
Last page: 50
Web address : https://journals.lub.lu.se/pjos/article/view/16454
The slogan in the title of this article is meaningless in a context where the notion of “sum” does not apply. It is false in a context where the whole is equal to (or indistinguishable from) the sum of its parts. Having only a metaphorical meaning, it is neither clearly true nor clearly false in a context where no numerical value can be assigned to this relation of magnitude (which is typically the case in linguistics). In this article, however, a unit of measurement is devised which makes it possible to decide whether a linguistic whole is greater or smaller than the sum of its parts. In the former case the slogan is true whereas in the latter case it is, once again, false.