Frameworks in Historiography: Explanation, Scenarios, and Futures
: Virmajoki Veli
Publisher: Brill
: 2023
: Journal of the Philosophy of History
: J. Philos. Hist.
: 17
: 2
: 288
: 309
: 1872-2636
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/18722636-12341501
: https://brill.com/view/journals/jph/17/2/article-p288_6.xml?language=en
: https://philpapers.org/rec/VIRFIH
In this paper, I analyze how frameworks shape historiographical explanations. I argue that, in order to identify a sequence of events as relevant to a historical outcome, assumptions about the workings of the relevant domain have to be made. By extending Lakatosian considerations, I argue that these assumptions are provided by a framework that contains a set of factors and intertwined principles that (supposedly) govern how a historical phenomenon works. I connect frameworks with a counterfactual account of historical explanation. Frameworks enable us to explain the past by providing a backbone of explanatory patterns of counterfactual dependency. I conclude by noting that both counterfactual scenarios and scenarios of the future require frameworks and, therefore, historiographical explanation generates a set of possible futures. Analyzing these possible futures enables us to reveal the theoretical commitments of historiography.