Instruments for assessing reasoning skills in higher education: a scoping review

: Kirsi Talman, Jonna Vierula, Anne-Maria Kanerva, Outi Virkki, Jaana-Maija Koivisto, Elina Haavisto

Publisher: ROUTLEDGE JOURNALS, TAYLOR & FRANCIS LTD

: 2020

: Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education

: ASSESSMENT & EVALUATION IN HIGHER EDUCATION

: ASSESS EVAL HIGH EDU

: 17

: 0260-2938

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02602938.2020.1776212

Reasoning skills are needed in the future work life. As such, it is important that reasoning skills be assessed in higher education, both in the selection phase and during education. This study aims to describe the instruments that are used to assess reasoning skills in higher education. The ultimate goal is to provide information upon which student selection methods may be developed. A computerised search was performed among nine databases, and seventeen articles were included. As a result, seven generic instruments that measure reasoning skills were identified. None of the included studies reported an assessment of reasoning skills during the student selection phase. The content of the reasoning skills' instruments focused on four categories: information processing, analysing, drawing conclusions and argumentation. None of the seven instruments addressed all four categories identified, although a few addressed three categories. To conclude, a comprehensive assessment of reasoning skills including the four identified categories is recommended in the higher education context. Further research is needed to assess the use of reasoning skills and relevant instruments for high stake purposes.