Bulding bridges over the the great divide
: Nurmi Hannu
: Sacha Kurz, Nicola Maaser, Alexander Mayer
Publisher: Springer Nature Switzerland
: Cham
: 2023
: Advances in Collective Decision Making - Interdisciplinary Perspectives for the 21st Century
: Studies in Choice and Welfare
: 9
: 24
: 15
: 978-3-031-21695-4
: 978-3-031-21696-1
: 1614-0311
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-21696-1(external)
We discuss some methods aiming to reconcile Borda's and Condorcet's winning intuitions in the theory of voting. We begin with a brief summary of the advantages and disadvantages of binary and positional voting rules. We then review in some detail Black's, Nanson's and Dodgson's rules as well as the relatively recently introduced methods based on supercovering relation over the candidate set. These are evaluated in terms of some well-known choice-theoretic criteria.